MASSLINE.NET - Science Group: Review & comments page: Billions and Billions
Ye Olde Natural Philosophy Discussion Group
== Reviews and comments on Carl Sagan: "Billions and Billions" [1998] ==
Our group had a variety of opinions and ratings for this book. At the low end, Shel said that he was really disappointed with the book, and bored. He rated it only 3 (on a scale of 0-10). Most of us were more positive than negative, giving it ratings in the 5 to 7 range. Many of us thought it is an important book, but since the intended audience is so broad, it does not assume very much of the reader and repeats a lot of things our group already knew. Since the book is attempting to educate the public on important scientific issues it has a political flavor (which is not a criticism!). Rosie remarked that "it's not a science book; it's more of a political book."
Kirby and John were very enthusiastic about the book, both giving it 10's. Kirby gave it an empassioned defense, pointing out how important it is to educate large numbers of people in scientific matters. And all the more so when we realize how poorly educated in science most people are, and when we see things like the Kansas School Board denying basic science like evolution a place in the schools.
John Lewis wrote the following mini-review:
Return to our complete list of books.
Return to our Science Group home page.