Scott Harrison: Philosophical Argumentation

Argument

     In every sphere of thought and investigation, not just in philosophy, there is need for argument and disputation in order to help get to the truth. But philosophy is the most general sphere of investigation and disputation. It is entirely natural and proper that it must therefore also investigate and discuss argumentation itself.

     Roy Tedoff sent me the following nifty poem which well serves to introduce this topic:

     There are, of course, those who claim not to believe in the use of rational argument, though—most curiously!—they themselves often try to use (what they would consider to be) rational argument in an attempt to convince us that using rational argument is a waste of time! (See: IRRATIONALISM )

     We must also note that no matter what you say in philosophy, there will be those who argue against you. To be a philosopher is to stand your ground at least until those arguments start to make some sense to you!

Some philosophers, I must alert you, Will be found who will still controvert you      But outlandish views      Of various hues Should def'nitely not disconcert you.      —JSH, "Advice to a New Philosopher" (1992)

      Return to Main Index